Manual Vs Automatic Pool Vacuums: Which is Better?

Maintaining a clean and inviting swimming pool is essential for any pool owner, and pool vacuums play a vital role in this upkeep. Whether you opt for automatic or manual pool vacuums, having the right cleaning equipment can make the task much more manageable - especially when dealing with leaves, twigs, and general debris that can end up in your pool. 

Manual pool vacuums require a more hands-on approach for spot cleaning and give you more control, while automatic pool vacuums offer convenience and efficiency, so both have their place.

In this guide, we’ll explore the difference between manual and automatic pool vacuums, weighing the pros and cons of each to help you decide which option is best for your swimming pool maintenance needs.

 

the bottom of a swimming pool

 

What are Automatic Pool Vacuums?

Automatic pool vacuums, such as the Hayward SharkVac, are robotic vacuum cleaners with their own navigation system powered by electricity designed to clean your pool automatically with little intervention. These intelligent machines navigate the pool’s surface and walls, using sensors to detect and remove debris, dirt, and algae. They operate independently of the pool’s filtration system, providing thorough cleaning without the need for manual interference. 

Pros of Automatic Pool Vacuums

Convenience

Automatic pool vacuums require minimal effort from the pool owner, as they can be programmed to clean the pool on a set schedule. This gives you the freedom to carry on with more exciting jobs that don’t involve cleaning!

Efficiency

These devices can clean large pools quickly and effectively, leaving your pool sparkling clean with minimal effort. 

Comprehensive Cleaning

Automatic pool vacuums are equipped with advanced features such as brushes and scrubbers, ensuring thorough cleaning of pool surfaces and walls. 

A pool owner cleaning their swimming pool

Cons of Automatic Pool Vacuums

Cost

As you may have guessed, automatic pool vacuums are more expensive than manual models, making them a significant investment for some pool owners.

Maintenance 

These devices require more regular maintenance and occasional repairs, adding to the overall cost of ownership. 

Limited Control

While automatic vacuums are efficient cleaners, they may not always reach every corner or crevice of the pool, requiring manual touch-ups. 

Shop now automatic pool vacuums

What are Manual Pool Vacuums?

On the other hand, manual pool vacuums are operated by - you guessed it, you! They require you to manually manoeuvre the device across the pool’s surface and walls. These vacuums are typically connected to a telescopic pole and hose, allowing for greater reach and control during cleaning.

Pros of Manual Pool Vacuums

Cost-effective

Manual pool vacuums are generally more affordable than their automatic counterparts, making them a budget-friendly option for pool owners. 

Versatility

With a manual pool vacuum, you have complete control over the cleaning process, allowing you to target specific pool areas that may require extra attention.

Easy Maintenance

Manual pool vacuums are simple in design and require minimal maintenance, reducing the overall cost of ownership.

Ariel shot of a swimming pool

Cons of Manual Pool Vacuums

Increased Labour

Using a manual pool vacuum requires physical effort and time, as you must manually manoeuvre the device across the pool’s surface and walls. 

Time-consuming

Cleaning a swimming pool, particularly if it’s large, with a manual vacuum can be time-consuming - especially if the pool has a significant amount of debris or algae build-up. This can also become even more difficult with an outdoor pool, as there tends to be more build-up.

Skill Required

Achieving optimal cleaning results with a manual pool vacuum may require some practice and skill, especially when it comes to manoeuvring the device effectively.

Shop now manual pool vacuums

 

The choice between manual and automatic pool vacuums ultimately depends on your preferences, budget, and pool maintenance needs. Automatic pool vacuums offer convenience and efficiency but have a higher price tag and ongoing maintenance requirements. 

Alternatively, manual pool vacuums are cost-effective and versatile but require more time and effort to operate. Consider your pool size, cleaning frequency, and personal preferences when deciding which type of swimming pool vacuum is right for you. 

Whether you opt for a hand-held or automatic pool vacuum, investing in quality pool cleaning equipment is essential for maintaining a clean and healthy swimming pool.

How to effectively vacuum your pool